Glorious Eclipses : Their Past, Present and Future
By Serge Brunier and Jean-Pierre Luminet
Cambridge University Press, New York, 2000 ($39.95)
An extrordinarily beautiful book, Glorious Eclipses guides us elegantly through the history of obscurations of the sun and moon - from the ancient Chinese belief that a dragon was devouring the daytime star through current theories and on to celestial events forthcoming in the next six decades. Some of the most startling images come from the days when photography was in its infancy and astronomers still made drawings of eclipses.
Published in time for Junes eclipse across southern Africa, the book, by Serge Brunier, former editor of the magazine Ciel et Espace, and Luminet, a research director at CNRS, is translated from the French.
Scientific American, June 2001
Darkness at noon
At first sight, this is the ultimate eclipse book. Oversize, well-produced photographs in a large-format book are accompanied by interesting text covering a wide variety of eclipses phenomena. The partnership of an astronomer writer/editor and a professional astronomer, albeit a cosmologist, successfully brings the beauty of total solar eclipses to the fore.
Although the writers alternate, the difference is not jarring, perhaps thanks to the expert translator, Storm Dunlop. In a chapter entitled "The great cosmic clockwork", Serge Brunier, long-time editor of the French popular astronomy journal Ciel et Espace, discusses the many kinds of eclipses and occultations (when one astronomical body occults, or hides, another). He even includes the eagerly awaited 2004 transit of Venus - the passage of Venus across the face of the Sun. This will be the first transit of Venus visibe from Earth since 1882.
The reproduction of photographs in 25 cm x 35 cm format on heavy stock is outstanding. For example, we see Saturn's rings extending across a double page for almost half a metre in a Hubble Space Telescope image. The authors justify using this image, which shows the shadow of Saturn's satellite Titan on Saturn's clouds, by pointing out that it corresponds to an eclipse of the Sun by Titan as seen from Saturn. It's a pity, though, that Brunier calls himself an "eclipse chaser" - that common but misleading phrase seemps to imply that people can outrun, or even outfly, eclipses, which has never been done.
Brunier is responsible for some of the most magnificent photographs, such as one from the 1991 total solar eclipse visible from the Mauna Kea Observatory in Hawaii, with a few telescopes in the foreground. But the image I found most arresting is not one of this; it is a wide-angle shot of the 1991 eclipse viewed through a hole in the clouds and showing the front of Reims Cathedral in the left foreground.
In his chapters on the history and cultural significance of eclipses, Jean-Pierre Luminet reproduces a remarkable set of historical images related to solar and lunar eclipses from around the world. These are no doubt related to his work on an exhibition of astronomical atlases held in Paris at the Bibliothèque Nationale in 1998.
It was good to read about myths that cast eclipses in a favourable light rather than as evil omens. Luminet also describes the history of scientific discovery through observations of solar eclipses. One example is the discovery at the 1868 total solar eclipse of the spectrum of the solar chomosphere - the layer of the Sun just above the surface that becomes briefly visible at the beginning and end of totality. The element helium was also discovered at this eclipse.
There is much that is excellent in the book. The charts of future eclipses at the end of the book are redrawn at the highest quality. Lunar eclipses are included in the text, photos and charts, looking almost as dramatic on the page as the solar ecipses, even though they are much less so in reality. As a book of history, myth, literature, photography and expeditionary experiences, Glorious Eclipses is outstanding, despite its omission of the solar research carried out at recent eclipses.
Jay Pasachoff, Nature, vol. 410, 29 march 2001.
Wonder of day turned into light
A total eclipse of the Sun is about as astonishing a treat as nature provides. For a few minutes, the Moon exactly covers the Sun, making night from day and displaying the otherwise invisible solar atmosphere. This book celebrates eclipses of both Sun and Moon (the rather less spectacular sweeping of Earth's shadow across the lunar surface) from many directions, including the complex history of eclipse observations and their declining but still real scientific value.
Serge Brunier and Jean-Pierre Luminet are respectively a science journalist and photographer, and a senior astronomer. This book, well translated from French by Storm Dunlop, makes the most of their strengths. It displays a deep understanding of history, some gripping science and a wealth of images, both of eclipses and of the many ways in which they have been represented over the years.
If you want to take up eclipse chasing, the book's maps of future eclipses will tell you when and where to be, and its illstrations will tell you what to expect and how to observe in safety. There are explanations of the eclipse cycle, or Saros, and of the fact that in the far future, there will be no more solar elipses as the Moon's distance from the Earth increases.
The book also provides generous coverage of lunar eclipses and of related events such as occultations and transits. There is even space to reveal how planets in other solar systems are being detected as they eclipse their own star as seen from Earth. Eclipses still make cutting-edge science thousands of years after they first caused dismay to our ancestors.
Martin Ince, Deputy Editor, The Times Higher, March 9 2001.
Review in Astronomy & Geophysics, 2001 December (Vol.42), 6.33
Not in the shade
Glorious Eclipses: Their Past, Present And Future,
Serge Brunier and Jean-Pierre Luminet, Cambridge University Press, 2000, £2500, hbk,
ISBN O 521 79148 0.
This attractive and beautifully illustrated book, by two Paris astronomers and dedicated eclipse-chasers, was originally published in French under the title Eclipses, Les Rendez-vous Celestes (Larousse-Bordas/HER, 1999). The present English translation is by Storm Dunlop. This book is a veritable mine of information on eclipses and is suitable for anyone who has an interest in eclipses, be they amateur or professional astronomer, photographer or historian.
The scene is set in the first chapter, which captures much of the appeal of total solar eclipses and leaves the reader in no doubt as to why eclipse chasers will travel vast distances to witness a few minutes of totality.
In chapters two and three, the historical and literary aspects of both solar and lunar eclipses are discussed. Although there is some sound history in the first of these chapters, there is also much speculation especially with regard to such torical and literary aspects of both such diverse matters as Stonehenge, Thales, and the date of the Crucifixion of Jesus. Regrettably, there are several serious errors. Thus the "Assyrian tablet dating from the
2nd century BC" (p40) is in fact from Babylonia, several centuries after the demise of Assyria. Thucydides reports three eclipses, not just two (p43). "According to the Evangelists," Jesus was not "crucified on a Thursday," (p44). Chapter three contains some intriguing literary allusions to eclipses in prose and poetry both ancient and modern.
Chapters four to seven provide the main substance of this book and are both fascinating and informative. They deal respectively with: the cause of both lunar and solar eclipses; lunar and planetary occultations and also Mercury and Venus transits; total solar eclipse phenomena; and the famous or infamous (depending on the wearher) 1999 eclipse. In particular, it is gond to see a discussion of occultations and transits which, in a sense, are eclipses in their own right.
The final chapter contains helpful hints for observing and photographing eclipses and also a series of attractive maps showing the visibility of future solar and lunar eclipses with special emphasis on those over the next 20 years. Unfortunately many of the individual solar eclipse maps (p15669) are confusing; in each case the maps show "Total eclipse begins at sunrise", "Path of totality" and "Total eclipse ends at sunset" whether the eclipse was annular or total.
Overall, this is a splendid hook, profusely illustrated.
F Richard Stephenson.